CITY OF SAN ANTONIO v. WHEELABRATOR AIR POLLUTION CONTROL, INC.
Court of Appeals of Texas, Fourth District, San Antonio.
Delivered and Filed: August 1, 2012.
PHYLIS J. SPEEDLIN, Justice.
The City of San Antonio, acting by and through CPS Energy1 (hereinafter “CPS”), appeals the trial court’s denial of its plea to the jurisdiction in this lawsuit by Wheelabrator Air Pollution Control, Inc. in which it asserts a breach of contract claim and, alternatively, a quasi-contractual quantum meruit claim to recover a 10% contract retainage withheld by CPS. This interlocutory appeal raises a question of first impression—whether the governmental/proprietary distinction employed in the Texas Tort Claims Act applies in a contractual or quasi-contractual setting to determine whether a municipality is immune from suit. We hold that the governmental/proprietary distinction does not apply, and conclude CPS is immune from suit on the quantum meruit claim. Accordingly, we reverse the trial court’s order denying CPS’s plea to the jurisdiction, render judgment dismissing Wheelabrator’s quantum meruit claim for want of jurisdiction, and remand the cause to the trial court for further proceedings.
Because the Legislature’s limited waiver of governmental immunity from suit in Chapter 271 does not include quantum meruit claims, and the proprietary/governmental distinction from the TTCA does not apply in this contractual or quasi-contractual context, CPS is immune from suit on Wheelabrator’s quantum meruit claim. In addition, the circumstances do not support a waiver of immunity by conduct. Therefore, the trial court erred in denying CPS’s plea to the jurisdiction as to the quantum meruit claim. Accordingly, we reverse the trial court’s order denying CPS’s plea to the jurisdiction and render judgment that Wheelabrator’s quantum meruit claim is dismissed for want of jurisdiction. We remand the cause to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
BOCA.DENTIST available now! Get it today!
- There are over 2 million dentists working in the world, and many rely on technology to operate a successful practice.
- From finding patients online, to providing patient information portals, the importance of a visible, functional, and market-specific can’t be understated.
- BOCA.DENTIST provides the perfect TLD option for dental practices, and is a relevant, targeted domain extension option made explicitly for the dental world.
- Use BOCA.DENTIST to help better connect with current and new patients.
Interested in buying this domain? Drop us a line and let's see if we can take your business to the next level.
Tips and Public Leads
Please use this website to report suspected corrupt or criminal activity. Due to the high volume of information that we receive, we are unable to reply to every submission; however, we appreciate the information that you have provided.Submit an anonymous tip.